Six Problems With the @MyGR6 Contest

A word cloud of the "My GR 6" entries thus far...

A word cloud of the "My GR 6" entries thus far...

A group of local corporations partnered with community leaders to create a contest called “My GR 6.”  The contest awards acclaim (in the form of billboard space) and prizes to whomever comes up with the best six words that describe the city of Grand Rapids (according to a panel of judges that aren’t yet disclosed).

While it’s great to see any effort to foster community pride and raise the profile of my home city, I do have some issues with how it’s being accomplished.  Here are a few of my concerns:

1. It’s been done.

To wit:

If Grand Rapids truly wants to distinguish itself, it’s going to have to get past this tendency we have to glom onto whatever trend is happening and localize it.  C’mon people – I know we can do better.

2. It’s led by Amway.  

Personal opinions of Amway and its owners (both for/against) aside – does it really help expand the image of Grand Rapids to have this contest run by the company that is already the lazy comedic shorthand default for referring to the city?  Already, entries are being submitted referencing the multi-level marketing giant.  The company’s involvement appears to have already attracted the attention of the population of Amway-hating trolls (term used not as a pejorative – rather as a descriptor of the behavior) who are fairly populous on the web.

3. The entries are judged by “Grand Rapids business and community leaders.”

So … no regular citizens?  No kids?  No students?  The panel hasn’t been named yet, but those weren’t any of the groups of people named to be included.  The fine print of the entry form states:

All entries will be judged weekly as entries are submitted based on the following judging criteria all with equal value (“Judging Panel Criteria”):

  • Creativity
  • Originality
  • Relevance
  • Emotiveness

The Judging Panel will select semifinalists (each a “semifinalist”) based on the Judging Panel Criteria. The semifinalists’ entries will be presented to a final judging panel made of individuals from local media, government, education, business and cultural leaders (“Final Judging Panel”). The Final Judging Panel will select six (6) winners from the semifinalists on or about October 10, 2011.  

4. The judging criteria and censorship.

Again, the small print of the entry form states:

“Sponsor and judges reserve the right, in their sole and absolute discretion, to disqualify and reject any entries that are inappropriate for any reason, including without limitation, for containing profane or inappropriate language.”

As one entrant has already noted, the submission form automatically bans the words “pyramid” and “scheme” separately or together (which the form describes as “naughty” words).

This comes at a time when the popular new concert venue/bar is called “the Pyramid Scheme.”  Moreover one could also envision a lot of clever ways to positively describe the city using those words and poking fun at “pyramid schemes” to help the city transcend that misperception.

Amway isn’t doing itself (or the city) any favors by highlighting the primary criticism of the company in this way.  When “the Daily Show” and “the Colbert Report” are primary ways a sizable chunk of the public gets its news, taking oneself too seriously is a prescription for failure.

To its credit, the organizers haven’t taken down any of the negative contributions as far as I’m aware (…yet).

5. It will reinforce insularity at a time when understanding others perceptions of us is more important (and relevant).

No organization controls its brand; in fact – customers and outsiders have far more say over brand identity than any organization does.  This is an empirical reality reinforced daily by social media.  The problem is that the entries are censored, and the winners are invariably going to be enthusiastic and straight-laced.

Understanding the shortcomings of the city would be helpful at a time when West Michigan leaders are struggling to retain the young creative population as exemplified by a recent panel (“How can we grow a creative class in West Michigan? Holland, Grand Rapids and Norton Shores mayors to grapple with issue in free seminar” | Grand Rapids Press)

Of the 483 entries at the time of this post, seven percent (32) were decidedly negative, and hinted at some of the perceptual shortcomings and cultural facets of the city.  They ranged from societal criticisms to political statements.  Some were outright derisive, but others gently poked fun at the foibles of the city.  Among them:

  • “Stuck on reputation Ignores the realities.” | – Paula S., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Be like us…resistance is futile.” | – Locutus B., Grand Rapids, Michigan [props for the Star Trek reference]
  • “Like Mormons, but with normal underwear.” | – Straitup N., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “19th century mindset, 20th century policies” | – Stu J., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Amway censors “PIRAMID” & “SKEME” spelled correctly.” | – Julian A., Santibáñez de Esgueva, Castille and Leon
  • “Recruit friends to recruit friends to…” | – DutchMafia I., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Billions for corporations, zero for education.” | – Louisa K., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Ridiculously naive laughingstock of the nation.” | – Quaker H., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Grand Rapids. Both words are lies.” | – Pinocchio G., Kalamazoo, Michigan
  • “Planning ahead is not our strong” | – Blindinone I., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Where ‘adventure’ means an ethnic restaurant.” | – Jim V., Comstock Park, Michigan
  • “Penny wise, pound foolish = missed opportunities.” | – Khudda B., Comstock Park, Michigan
  • “Where Dutch white men run everything.” | – Nijer P., Jilotlán de los Dolores, Jalisco
  • “Always twenty years behind the times.” | – Eusta L., Jilotlán de los Dolores, Jalisco
  • “Not far enough away from Holland.” | – Paul S., Holland, Michigan
  • “pretty cool place, way too conservative” | – tom d., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “high taxes hurt my wallet badly” | – linda b., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “A right-wing, racist, Republican Eden.” | – Julie A., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Choking on the phlegm of conservatism” | – James D., Grand Rapids, Michigan
  • “Diversity equals both Dutch and Conservatives.” | – Timm S., Grand Rapids, Michigan

6. It’s not organic.

We’re living in the age of the user.  Social media is king.  The contest has propagated itself through a combination of traditional (read: tired) public relations tactics and it’s backed by entities that represent the establishment (even if only the perceived establishment).  That structure doesn’t jibe with the attempt the organizers are making to crowdsource the promotion of the city.  For example:

  • The already-mentioned censorship stifles contributions, thereby excluding certain populations and limiting creativity.
  • The contest has already been pre-populated with entries from well-known Grand Rapidians like Betty Ford, Peter Secchia, George Heartwell, Marvin Sapp, Peter Wege, the DeVos family, and (inexplicably) Molly Mesnick – a contestant on Season 13 of “The Bachelor.”
  • The story in the Grand Rapids Press (which is a sponsor) reads like a press release.
  • Is there anything less organic than teasing something with vague declarations that culminate in a big reveal? (Think: “Gabbo! Gabbo! GABBO!”)

For whatever it’s worth, I wish the people behind the contest luck and I’ll be watching with interest – I hope we can aim higher for the next iteration.

About these ads
  1. July 6, 2011 at 7:43 am

    Grand Rapids is actually already doing so much to reinvent its image through Art Prize and Rob Bliss Events. I think they should stick to focusing on projects like those vs. this contest!

    Like

  2. July 6, 2011 at 11:46 am

    OH: I thought that was a local campaign for the Motel 6 :)

    Like

    • July 7, 2011 at 8:27 am

      OH MAN. I kind of thought so too when I saw the big six.

      Like

  3. July 6, 2011 at 4:34 pm

    When I worked for a large corp, I ran an internal slogan contest.

    We had 2 categories: “best slogan” and “worst slogan”.

    The worst slogans were usually much more fun to read than the best! It also gave us business insights about potential internal problems. You can’t work on solving problems until you actually admit that they exist.

    Why not a “worst slogan” contest? That might prove more helpful — as well as creative and entertaining!

    What’s the point of this contest again?

    Like

    • July 7, 2011 at 8:26 am

      Funny you should mention that; I actually have an idea for a contest along those lines ready to go. I’m trying to work out the logistics of how we’d process entries, but that can probably just be done with wall posts on a Facebook page or by tweeting at the Twitter account I’ve created.

      I’m with you – why does everything have to always be so uptight, serious and earnest? The worst / snarky slogans are invariably the best. I’ve tossed those out in meetings at work and invariably they get big laughs but it always comes down to “no – we’d never get that past the c-suite:”

      Like

  4. July 7, 2011 at 1:41 pm

    Honestly.

    If a city can’t laugh at itself: it can forget any notion at all that it’s the “cool city” it purports to be.

    Let me know about your worst6. I’ll bet it’ll be a hoot to read!

    Like

  5. Andrew
    September 8, 2011 at 5:02 pm

    At least they’re doing something besides taking pot shots from your lazyboy. What an asshole you are. No wonder you don’t have any friends. Lol.

    Like

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,682 other followers

%d bloggers like this: